17-year-old orphan faces court over 5-million-lekë fine for protest participation

  • Share
17-year-old orphan faces court over 5-million-lekë fine for protest participation

Guest on *Now with Erla Mehilli*, criminalistics expert Ervin Karamuço discusses the case of an orphaned minor fined 5 million lekë by police for taking part in protests. Karamuço argues that when assessing penalties for protesters, all circumstances—including age, social status, and economic hardship—must be considered, particularly for the 17-year-old in question.

Karamuço emphasizes that it is the court’s role to determine whether the fine imposed by police is proportionate to the minor’s actions and whether the measure aligns with the specific circumstances of the case.

“In every case, all circumstances must be taken into account—the fact that he is a minor, that he faces social challenges, lives in difficult conditions, and economic hardship. All of these factors must be presented to the court in reaching a decision. This case highlights that, alongside protesters with legitimate grievances, there are also those who protest for these very conditions we’ve discussed. There is a legitimate demand for change, even among minors in this specific case. However, the issue is that police have two options: administrative penalties or criminal prosecution. Both apply equally to minors and adults. Are these measures proportionate and lawful? Of course they are, but only if they align with the specific circumstances. The court decides this. We cannot pre-judge whether the police fine against the 17-year-old’s actions was proportionate or not. There have been cases where individuals claimed they weren’t at the protest, but later, documentary or film evidence proved otherwise—some even violently attacked police with Molotov cocktails and similar weapons,” Karamuço stated.

The post 17-year-old orphan faces court over fine: Karamuço says all circumstances must be examined appeared first on Euronews Albania.


Source: euronews.al
Note: This material has been processed for informational purposes by Portali Kosova.Today.


4 views 0 sot