Kosovo

Lost coins at markets could be prevented with POS payments, experts say

Kosova.Today ·

POS payments could help avoid the issue of missing change, while the use of cards and electronic payments in Kosovo is on the rise. The Central Bank of Kosovo (BQK) states that digital payments ensure accurate transaction amounts, while the Chamber of...

POS payments could avoid the issue of change not being returned, while the use of cards and electronic payments in Kosovo is on the rise. The Central Bank of Kosovo (BQK) states that digital payments enable the exact amount to be paid, whereas the Chamber of Commerce considers the withholding of cents a violation of consumers' rights.

Arben Krasniqi last Monday had gone out to make his usual purchases at the market. His bill came to €52.97, but when it came time to pay, he handed over €53, and the remaining three cents were not returned.

For such a small amount, Arben says it’s not worth starting a debate in the market, but he emphasizes that this practice is not right, especially when it happens almost every time.

Such cases are not unfamiliar to other citizens either. Alma Gashi also says she often faces situations where one or two cents are not returned. For her, the best solution is card payments, as the exact amount on the bill is paid, and no change is left to be returned.

Bedri Ahmeti, however, thinks differently and continues to prefer cash payments. He says cash payments seem easier and more practical for daily purchases, regardless of cases where the full change is not returned.

But what may seem like a negligible loss of one, two, or three cents to some citizens can turn into a significant amount in a large number of transactions.

The withholding of change in markets and other businesses in Kosovo raises concerns about respecting consumers' rights and the responsibility of economic operators. Meanwhile, the expansion of electronic payments is seen as one of the ways to avoid this problem.

Data from the Central Bank of Kosovo shows that card payments during the January-September 2026 period increased by around 37 percent compared to the same period the previous year. Meanwhile, online payments saw a rise of around 32 percent.

But how much are citizens really losing from the cents that are not returned? Does this practice constitute a violation of consumers' rights, and are POS payments the best solution to avoid it?

Withholding change: a potential profit for businesses at the expense of consumers

The Executive Director of the Kosovo Chamber of Commerce and Industry (KCCI), Kushtrim Ahmeti, told ORAinfo that withholding change—whether it’s one, two, or five cents—constitutes a violation of consumers' rights, as defined in the Consumer Protection Law.

According to him, this practice is still common in some sectors of trade, although improvements have been noted in larger markets as a result of public pressure.

Ahmeti emphasizes that the persistent withholding of change can create financial benefits for economic operators.

“If a small amount is not returned to the consumer in a single transaction, it may seem insignificant, but when repeated hundreds or thousands of times a day, it can eventually add up to substantial sums,” he says.

However, KCCI does not have an exact estimate of what these gains might be.

Selatin Kaçaniku, founder of the non-governmental organization “Konsumatori” (Consumer), also considers this issue troubling and a violation of citizens' rights and dignity.

He urges consumers to insist on receiving their full change, regardless of its value.

“Citizen consumers must demand that every cent is returned,” Kaçaniku told ORAinfo.

According to him, card payments would help avoid this problem, although not all consumers prefer them. Kaçaniku also mentions concerns about cybersecurity and negative experiences some citizens may have had with bank cards.

Electronic payments: a solution to avoid losing even a single cent

The Central Bank of Kosovo assesses that wider use of electronic payments could contribute to eliminating issues during cash transactions.

“Digital payments enable the exact amount of the bill to be transferred, regardless of its value, avoiding the need for physical change and reducing cases where consumers do not receive the full value of the remaining amount,” the BQK stated in response to ORAinfo.

According to this institution, the new payment infrastructure will also enable direct transfers from account to account in near real-time and at low cost, increasing transaction transparency.

Increase in card payments and expansion of the POS network

Despite the challenges, data from the Central Bank of Kosovo shows that the use of electronic payment instruments is rising.

According to the annual report of the BQK’s Payment Systems Department, in 2025 there were a total of 30,259 POS terminals in Kosovo, compared to 20,882 in 2024. This represents an increase of around 45 percent within one year.

In the same year, there were 1,546,633 active debit cards and 218,232 credit cards in Kosovo.

Electronic banking services have also seen growth. The number of e-banking accounts reached 1,225,962 in 2025, up from 411,346 in 2020.

The upward trend has continued into 2026.

In response to ORAinfo, the BQK stated that during the January-September 2026 period, compared to the same period the previous year, card payments increased by around 37 percent, while online payments rose by around 32 percent.

According to the BQK, this increase reflects growing citizen trust in digital services, the expansion of electronic payment acceptance by businesses, and investments in modernizing financial infrastructure.

The BQK aims to expand electronic payments even to small businesses

In addition to the rise in card usage, the BQK states that one of its priorities is expanding the acceptance of electronic payments in small and micro-businesses.

Within the framework of the BQK’s 2024-2028 Strategy, one of the key objectives is modernizing the financial market infrastructure and promoting the use of electronic payments.

One of the key projects is the **Fast Payment System, TIPS-K**, which is expected to enable instant payments 24 hours a day, seven days a week.

Through this system, payments via mobile phones, QR codes, and identifiers such as phone numbers are also intended to be facilitated.

The Central Bank of Kosovo (BQK) emphasizes that these solutions can reduce the costs of accepting payments and ease the inclusion of small businesses in the digital economy.

However, businesses currently have no general legal obligation to offer card or other electronic payments.

According to the BQK, the decision to equip with POS devices remains at the discretion of each business, except in cases where legal limits on cash payments apply.

Businesses seek lower POS fees

Meanwhile, the Kosovo Business Alliance (AKB) supports the expansion of electronic payments but argues that this process must be accompanied by affordable conditions for businesses.

AKB Chairman Agim Shahini told ORAinfo that banking fees remain a barrier, particularly for small businesses.

According to him, the obligation to equip with POS devices must be accompanied by lower fees, modern alternatives, and financial support for small businesses.

Shahini believes that failing to return change undermines consumer rights and trust in the market, while digital payments could reduce this issue.

He calls on institutions and banks to lower banking fees, develop more flexible alternatives, and implement a gradual digitalization plan in consultation with businesses.

The Kosovo Chamber of Commerce (DHTIK) has also urged the BQK to take greater responsibility for supplying the market with coins, as businesses have previously reported difficulties in obtaining these from commercial banks.

MINTI does not respond to fines and consumer complaints

To gain a clearer picture of the oversight of this issue and the measures being taken to protect consumers, questions were also directed to the Ministry of Industry, Entrepreneurship and Trade (MINTI).

The ministry was asked how many fines the Central Market Oversight Inspectorate has imposed on markets and businesses for failing to return full change, including one-, two-, and five-cent coins, as well as how many complaints citizens have filed regarding this issue in 2026.

The ministry was also asked about concrete plans linking consumer protection to the digitalization of payments and the impact that expanding electronic payments could have on reducing the informal economy in Kosovo.

However, as of this report’s publication, MINTI has not responded to the questions sent.
As a result, it remains unclear how many such cases have been documented by the Market Inspectorate, what disciplinary measures have been taken against businesses, and what concrete steps are being planned to prevent this practice.

Meanwhile, the Kosovo Tax Administration has stated that data related to these issues are provided by fiscal archive reports. Valentina Bytyqi-Sefa, Head of the Media Communication Division at the KTA, emphasized to ORAinfo that the institution lacks legal authority or capacity to further address cases where remaining amounts are not returned to consumers.

On the other hand, DHTIK considers that responsibility for respecting consumer rights primarily lies with economic operators, while oversight institutions must monitor law enforcement and respond to violations.

How much can a citizen lose from unreturned cents?

While there is no official statistic on consumer losses from unreturned cents, the impact can be understood through the recurrence of such cases.

For example, if a consumer is not given back two cents per day, this amounts to €7.30 over a year. If such a situation affects 1,000 consumers daily, the total sum would reach €7,300 annually.

This is merely a mathematical illustration, not an assessment of actual losses in Kosovo.

While POS payments can prevent this issue, respecting consumer rights and returning full change remain the responsibility of businesses, regardless of the payment method.

Ultimately, digitalization could be one of the solutions for more accurate, transparent, and practical payments, but consumer protection also requires stronger oversight and compliance with regulations by all economic operators. /ORAinfo/


Source of the news: orainfo.net
Note: This material has been adapted for informational purposes by the Portal Kosova.Today.

Read on the full page
Të ngjashme

67 traffic accidents in Kosovo: 19 injured, no fatalities

17.11.2026

Kosovo Assembly to Vote on Special Court Law – Key Points

17.11.2026

PDK: No party member harbours ill intent for Special Law, says Çitaku

17.11.2026

Kosovo Government Criticises Special Court Over Hashim Thaçi’s Reconviction

17.11.2026