The Kremlin is demanding the withdrawal of NATO troops and bases to positions as they were in 1997, referring to the period before NATO’s first expansion toward Eastern Europe. This demand, raised during talks on ending the war in Ukraine, could significantly impact Europe’s security stability.
According to the **[New York Times](https://kosova.today/search?q=New+York+Times)**, a document presented by Russian representatives in Abu Dhabi, dated November 10, calls not only for the cessation of Western arms supplies to Ukraine but also for NATO troops and bases to be withdrawn to their 1997 levels.
---
### **What Does "1997" Mean for NATO?**
The year 1997 marks the period before NATO’s first expansion into Eastern Europe. At that time, the alliance had only 16 members, while Poland, the Czech Republic, and Hungary were still in the process of joining—officially acceding two years later. After this period, countries from Central, Eastern, and Southeastern Europe gradually joined, increasing membership to 32 today.
The Kremlin is not explicitly calling for Eastern European nations to leave NATO but rather the withdrawal of NATO’s military presence in those territories, including bases and deployed forces established after 1997.
---
### **Consequences of NATO’s Withdrawal**
A withdrawal of NATO troops and bases would severely weaken the defensive capabilities of member states that joined after 1997. A notable example is Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania, which lack their own fighter jets to patrol their airspace. This responsibility currently falls to NATO, including the deployment of German troops like the Bundeswehr.
If this support were removed, the security of the Baltic states would be at risk. For instance, the **Mihail Kogălniceanu** airbase in Romania, set to become NATO’s largest base in Europe after completion of construction, would lose its strategic importance.
Poland’s Prime Minister **[Donald Tusk](https://kosova.today/search?q=Donald+Tusk)** has stated that “we will not allow any country to impose new security rules over the heads of Poland and Europe.” Bulgaria’s Prime Minister **[Rumen Radev](https://sq.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rumen_Radev)** called the Russian demand “unimaginable and unrealistic.” Estonia’s Prime Minister **[Kristen Michal](https://kosova.today/search?q=Kristen+Michal)** also opposes the idea that Russia should have a say in Europe’s security architecture.
---
### **Why Is This Demand Dangerous?**
The resistance from Eastern NATO member states reflects fear that an agreement between Washington and Moscow could turn their security into a bargaining chip. If NATO withdraws, Russia might perceive an attack as posing less risk to itself.
Under **NATO’s Article 5**, member states are obligated to assist one another in the event of an attack. However, to prevent aggression, NATO must be able to respond swiftly and effectively. The deployment of forces on the eastern flank is a key element of this strategy.
---
### **What Were the Promises on NATO Expansion?**
During the reunification of Germany, then-U.S. Secretary of State **[James Baker](https://kosova.today/search?q=James+Baker)** and German Foreign Minister **[Hans-Dietrich Genscher](https://sq.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hans-Dietrich_Genscher)** discussed limiting NATO’s expansion into Eastern Europe. However, no binding agreement was ever reached.
In the **1997 NATO-Russia Founding Act**, both sides declared that they no longer considered each other adversaries. NATO stated that it aimed to ensure collective defense through reinforcements, not through permanent deployment of combat forces. The treaty does not grant Moscow any veto rights.
The **1994 Budapest Memorandum**, in which Russia, the U.S., and the UK pledged to Ukraine, contained no obligation for military protection in the event of an attack. NATO membership was not a topic at the time.
---
### **Why Is This Demand Back on the Table?**
The document published by the **[New York Times](https://kosova.today/search?q=New+York+Times)** represents a negotiating position without official backing but reflects previously known Russian demands. In December 2021, Russia had presented two draft agreements with the U.S. and NATO, calling for a halt to further expansions.
In the agenda for talks in Abu Dhabi, alongside demands for NATO troop withdrawals, security guarantees post-war and a future security architecture for Europe are included. If negotiated alongside an end to the war in Ukraine, the Kremlin would gain additional leverage.
The Kremlin claims that NATO’s expansion and its military presence in Eastern Europe are the “root causes” of the war. However, no Western actor is willing to accept these demands. The former Polish intelligence coordinator **[Stanisław Żaryn](https://sq.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanisław_Żaryn)** interprets the talks as an attempt to buy time and weaken the West.
The Polish newspaper **[Gazeta Wyborcza](https://sq.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gazeta_Wyborcza)** considers a return to the 1997 status quo just as unrealistic as Finland leaving NATO.
---
### **In Brief**
Russia’s demand for NATO to revert to its 1997 positions would weaken the security of European nations that joined afterward, undermining their defensive capabilities and increasing the risk of aggression from Russia. Meanwhile, NATO members remain committed to preserving their sovereignty and rejecting Russian demands.
The Kremlin is attempting to negotiate independently of the end of the war in Ukraine, seeking extraordinary rights in Europe’s security architecture. However, this will face strong resistance from NATO members and Western partners.
James Baker - Former US Secretary of State
Stanisław Żaryn - Former coordinator of Polish secret services
News source: ina-online.net
Note: This content has been processed for informational purposes by Portali Kosova.Today.