Çitaku: International actors should contribute to amending the Law on Specialist Chambers after its re-vote

  • Share
Çitaku: International actors should contribute to amending the Law on Specialist Chambers after its re-vote

Vlora Çitaku, the acting leader of the opposition Democratic Party of Kosovo (PDK), says she expects a session to be called this week to re-vote on the Law on Kosovo’s Specialist Chambers.

In remarks to Radio Free Europe, Çitaku said that once the law is approved, the process of amending it will begin, urging international partners to contribute to the effort.

Last week, the Assembly’s plenary session was adjourned for lack of a quorum, preventing deputies from voting on the amended Special Court Law.

The law was amended on 6 October. However, it was sent back to the Assembly by the Presidency at the request of the PDK. After it is re-approved, the PDK says it will begin the process of amending the law.

Radio Free Europe contacted the office of Assembly Speaker Albulena Haxhiu to ask when the session at which the law is on the agenda is expected to resume, but has received no response so far.

“Immediately after the vote, we will begin the amendment process to strengthen the law and reinforce its legal robustness. We invite our international partners to contribute through substantive consultations and concrete proposals. Our demand for a fair process, cooperation with partners and Kosovo’s European path do not exclude one another,” Çitaku told Radio Free Europe.

Changes to the Law on the Specialist Chambers have drawn criticism from the European Union, which warned that they conflict with Kosovo’s international obligations.

The amendments were adopted following the 16 September conviction of four former Kosovo Liberation Army leaders. Former President Hashim Thaçi, former Assembly Speaker Kadri Veseli, former deputy Jakup Krasniqi and former deputy Rexhep Selimi were found guilty of war crimes. The defence is preparing to appeal the first-instance ruling, while the government has set up a working group to draft an appeal strategy.

Çitaku said that in this challenging period for Kosovo, maintaining internal cohesion requires “maturity, cooperation and determination.”

She said she expects the law to be the first item on the agenda at the next session and expressed confidence that all parties will show “constructiveness and responsibility,” as they did on 6 October when the same law was approved.

“On the eve of a decision on the administration of justice, the injustices of this process make the law that aims to restore the court to its intended purpose—justice—more urgent than ever,” Çitaku said.

She was referring to the verdict against Thaçi and others accused of obstructing justice. In that case, the Hague Prosecutor’s Office has requested a six-year prison sentence for the former President of Kosovo.

The changes to the Law on the Specialist Chambers were supported by deputies from the ruling Vetëvendosje Movement and the Alliance for the Future of Kosovo. Vetëvendosje has said it will vote for the law again, but has also expressed “inexplicable unease” and “serious doubts” about its enforceability.

Why was the Special Court Law sent back to the Assembly?

On 22 October, Kosovo’s President, Justina Shiroka Pula, sent the amended law, approved on 6 October, back to the Assembly at the PDK’s request. The party argued that the aim was to strengthen the law’s legal basis and ensure its practical implementation.

Now, the PDK is calling for the law to be approved again without changes to its content, while deficiencies are to be addressed through a new legislative initiative.

For the 6 October law to be considered adopted, at least 61 deputies must vote in favour; otherwise, it is deemed not adopted.

Nevertheless, even placing the Special Court Law on the agenda for re-voting has drawn reactions from international actors, who have expressed concern. The EU, which has called the amendments unacceptable, has also said it is holding consultations with the Kosovo government on the changes adopted on 6 October.

What does the October law envisage?

The amendments adopted on 6 October do not abolish the Specialist Court, which has handled war crimes and obstruction-of-justice cases and issued several rulings.

However, they do introduce changes on several key aspects of the court’s functioning.

One major change concerns the types of offences that fall within the court’s jurisdiction.

The amendments link the court’s jurisdiction to allegations of organ trafficking contained in the 2011 Parliamentary Assembly report of the Council of Europe, which prompted the creation of the Hague-based justice mechanism.

Under the law, the Hague court will handle acts directly related to allegations of illegal removal, harvesting and trafficking of organs, tissues or cells.

Its jurisdiction will also cover killings, torture and inhuman or degrading treatment in specific detention sites mentioned in the report, provided they are directly linked to alleged organ-harvesting operations.

This means the law aims to strip the Specialist Court of jurisdiction over other war crimes, crimes against humanity or politically motivated violence that lack such a direct connection.

Another significant change concerns the time frame. Under the original law, the Specialist Court was to handle crimes allegedly committed between January 1998 and December 2000.

The 6 October law narrows this period to between 1 July 1999 and 31 December 2000.

The amendments also stipulate that only crimes allegedly committed on Kosovo’s territory—not in northern Albania—will be handled. All cases outside the Specialist Court’s jurisdiction are to be transferred to Kosovo courts.

It is envisaged that cases already before the Supreme Court will be transferred to Kosovo.

The changes also affect the maximum penalty for convicted individuals, setting it at up to 15 years in prison.

In addition, those convicted by the Specialist Court, under the 6 October amendments, will be eligible for parole.

However, the latter clashes with the current law on pardons, which excludes the right to seek presidential pardon for certain crimes against international law, while Kosovo’s Criminal Code includes war crimes in this category.

The Specialist Chambers were established on the basis of a constitutional amendment, a special law and Kosovo’s international commitments.

Among these commitments was that Kosovo would consult the EU on any initiative to amend laws that affect the court’s mandate or the judicial procedures arising from investigations by the Specialist Prosecutor’s Office (SPO).

Kosovo also pledged to continue the work of the Specialist Chambers and the Specialist Prosecutor’s Office in The Hague until the completion of their respective investigations and proceedings.

Legal experts have previously warned that amendments affecting their mandate could raise constitutional issues and problems regarding the country’s international obligations.

The Specialist Chambers said they had not been consulted on the initiative, while Presiding Judge Ekaterina Trendafilova argued that the institution she leads guarantees independent and impartial proceedings in the service of justice, as she stated in a video message.


Source of the report: orainfo.net
Note: This material has been processed for informational purposes by the Kosovo.Today portal.


3 views 3 sot